Nigeria is approaching a dangerous tipping point of institutional failure, the Alliance for Economic Research and Ethics has warned.
It gave the warning in a policy brief titled The Broken Windows of Nigeria: How Government Neglect Forged a Nation of Self-Reliant Survivists—and the Uncommon Path to True Greatness, issued on Friday and signed by its Chairman, Dele Oye.
It stressed that decades of government neglect have forced citizens to provide essential services for themselves while weakening the authority of the state.
According to the group, Nigeria’s biggest challenge is no longer isolated failures in public services but the gradual breakdown of state institutions.
Drawing on the “Broken Windows Theory”, it said government neglect across critical sectors has created a cycle in which citizens increasingly rely on private alternatives for electricity, security, water, healthcare and education.
The group maintained that this growing dependence on self-provision has weakened public confidence in government while reducing pressure for meaningful reforms.
“This is not freedom. This is not entrepreneurship. This is trauma-induced self-reliance—a national coping mechanism so deeply internalised that many Nigerians no longer recognise it as abnormal,” the Alliance stated.
READ ALSO:
- CPPE Calls for Targeted Approach to Enforcing New Tax Laws
- Why Nigeria’s Power Crisis Defies Solution Since 1999
- Regulatory Clarity Key to Unlocking Nigeria’s Blockchain Potential — Rob Downes
- SEC Seeks Policy Stability for Frontier Market Return
It said repeated electricity grid collapses, rising insecurity, poor healthcare, inadequate infrastructure and the migration of skilled professionals all reflect deeper institutional weaknesses rather than isolated sectoral problems.
It noted that the country’s infrastructure deficit is estimated at $100 billion annually, while approximately 16,000 doctors left Nigeria within five years, leaving only about 55,000 medical doctors to serve a population of more than 230 million people.
According to the group, the failure of public institutions has compelled Nigerians to build parallel systems by purchasing generators, drilling private boreholes, hiring private security personnel and seeking medical care abroad.
It warned that while such measures help citizens cope with immediate challenges, they also deepen the long-term erosion of state capacity.
“When everyone has a generator, there is no constituency demanding grid reform. When everyone has private security, there is no political pressure for police reform. When everyone has a borehole, there is no outcry for public water,” the Alliance stated.
It acknowledged recent efforts by the Federal Government to address some of these challenges, including the approval of a ₦3.3 trillion payment plan to settle legacy electricity sector debts, the Electricity Act (Amendment) Bill 2025, the 2025 Police Regulations and the National Health Workforce Migration Policy.
However, it argued that while these measures represent important progress, they are insufficient to reverse decades of institutional decline.
“The government has begun to confront the depth of the crisis, but these are necessary, not sufficient. They are the ‘what’ of recovery. We need the ‘how’—and more importantly, the ‘why’ and the ‘who’,” the group said.
To reverse the trend, the Alliance proposed what it described as five transformative reforms aimed at rebuilding trust between citizens and the state.
Among its recommendations is a “Covenant of First Things,” under which government would guarantee access to basic public services, including electricity, security, clean water and primary healthcare within clearly defined timelines.
It also proposed the creation of a Citizen Dividend Fund to compensate Nigerians for part of the money they spend providing services the government should ordinarily deliver, with the rebates invested in public infrastructure bonds.
The group further called for a National Brain Regain Programme to encourage skilled Nigerians in the diaspora to return through equity participation in infrastructure projects and the establishment of special economic zones with improved governance and public services.
It also recommended an Institutional Memory Project to preserve the expertise of professionals before they leave the country, alongside a National Truth and Restitution Commission to document resource mismanagement, recover stolen assets and rebuild public trust.
The Alliance warned that unless decisive reforms are implemented, Nigeria risks further institutional decline as more citizens withdraw from public systems and rely entirely on private alternatives.
“The question is not whether Nigeria can be great. The question is whether Nigerians—citizens, leaders, diaspora and youth—have the collective will to repair what has been broken,” it added.
Alex is a business journalist cum data enthusiast with the Pinnacle Daily. He can be reached via ealex@thepinnacleng.com, @ehime_alex on X